src/media/filters/audio_decoder_unittest.cc

   1 // Copyright 2014 The Chromium Authors. All rights reserved.
   2 // Use of this source code is governed by a BSD-style license that can be
   3 // found in the LICENSE file.
   4
   5 #include <deque>
   6
   7 #include "base/bind.h"
   8 #include "base/format_macros.h"
   9 #include "base/md5.h"
  10 #include "base/message_loop/message_loop.h"
  11 #include "base/run_loop.h"
  12 #include "base/strings/stringprintf.h"
  13 #include "base/sys_byteorder.h"
  14 #include "build/build_config.h"
  15 #include "media/base/audio_buffer.h"
  16 #include "media/base/audio_bus.h"
  17 #include "media/base/audio_hash.h"
  18 #include "media/base/decoder_buffer.h"
  19 #include "media/base/test_data_util.h"
  20 #include "media/base/test_helpers.h"
  21 #include "media/ffmpeg/ffmpeg_common.h"
  22 #include "media/filters/audio_file_reader.h"
  23 #include "media/filters/ffmpeg_audio_decoder.h"
  24 #include "media/filters/in_memory_url_protocol.h"
  25 #include "media/filters/opus_audio_decoder.h"
  26 #include "testing/gtest/include/gtest/gtest.h"
  27
  28 namespace media {
  29
  30 // The number of packets to read and then decode from each file.
  31 static const size_t kDecodeRuns = 3;
  32 static const uint8_t kOpusExtraData[] = {
  33     0x4f, 0x70, 0x75, 0x73, 0x48, 0x65, 0x61, 0x64, 0x01, 0x02,
  34     // The next two bytes represent the codec delay.
  35     0x00, 0x00, 0x80, 0xbb, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00, 0x00};
  36
  37 enum AudioDecoderType {
  38   FFMPEG,
  39   OPUS,
  40 };
  41
  42 struct DecodedBufferExpectations {
  43   const int64 timestamp;
  44   const int64 duration;
  45   const char* hash;
  46 };
  47
  48 struct DecoderTestData {
  49   const AudioDecoderType decoder_type;
  50   const AudioCodec codec;
  51   const char* filename;
  52   const DecodedBufferExpectations* expectations;
  53   const int first_packet_pts;
  54   const int samples_per_second;
  55   const ChannelLayout channel_layout;
  56 };
  57
  58 // Tells gtest how to print our DecoderTestData structure.
  59 std::ostream& operator<<(std::ostream& os, const DecoderTestData& data) {
  60   return os << data.filename;
  61 }
  62
  63 // Marks negative timestamp buffers for discard or transfers FFmpeg's built in
  64 // discard metadata in favor of setting DiscardPadding on the DecoderBuffer.
  65 // Allows better testing of AudioDiscardHelper usage.
  66 static void SetDiscardPadding(AVPacket* packet,
  67                               const scoped_refptr<DecoderBuffer> buffer,
  68                               double samples_per_second) {
  69   // Discard negative timestamps.
  70   if (buffer->timestamp() + buffer->duration() < base::TimeDelta()) {
  71     buffer->set_discard_padding(
  72         std::make_pair(kInfiniteDuration(), base::TimeDelta()));
  73     return;
  74   }
  75   if (buffer->timestamp() < base::TimeDelta()) {
  76     buffer->set_discard_padding(
  77         std::make_pair(-buffer->timestamp(), base::TimeDelta()));
  78     return;
  79   }
  80
  81   // If the timestamp is positive, try to use FFmpeg's discard data.
  82   int skip_samples_size = 0;
  83   const uint32* skip_samples_ptr =
  84       reinterpret_cast<const uint32*>(av_packet_get_side_data(
  85           packet, AV_PKT_DATA_SKIP_SAMPLES, &skip_samples_size));
  86   if (skip_samples_size < 4)
  87     return;
  88   buffer->set_discard_padding(std::make_pair(
  89       base::TimeDelta::FromSecondsD(base::ByteSwapToLE32(*skip_samples_ptr) /
  90                                     samples_per_second),
  91       base::TimeDelta()));
  92 }
  93
  94 class AudioDecoderTest : public testing::TestWithParam<DecoderTestData> {
  95  public:
  96   AudioDecoderTest()
  97       : pending_decode_(false),
  98         pending_reset_(false),
  99         last_decode_status_(AudioDecoder::kDecodeError) {
 100     switch (GetParam().decoder_type) {
 101       case FFMPEG:
 102         decoder_.reset(new FFmpegAudioDecoder(
 103             message_loop_.message_loop_proxy(), LogCB()));
 104         break;
 105       case OPUS:
 106         decoder_.reset(
 107             new OpusAudioDecoder(message_loop_.message_loop_proxy()));
 108         break;
 109     }
 110   }
 111
 112   virtual ~AudioDecoderTest() {
 113     EXPECT_FALSE(pending_decode_);
 114     EXPECT_FALSE(pending_reset_);
 115   }
 116
 117  protected:
 118   void DecodeBuffer(const scoped_refptr<DecoderBuffer>& buffer) {
 119     ASSERT_FALSE(pending_decode_);
 120     pending_decode_ = true;
 121     last_decode_status_ = AudioDecoder::kDecodeError;
 122     decoder_->Decode(
 123         buffer,
 124         base::Bind(&AudioDecoderTest::DecodeFinished, base::Unretained(this)));
 125     base::RunLoop().RunUntilIdle();
 126     ASSERT_FALSE(pending_decode_);
 127   }
 128
 129   void SendEndOfStream() {
 130     DecodeBuffer(DecoderBuffer::CreateEOSBuffer());
 131   }
 132
 133   void Initialize() {
 134     // Load the test data file.
 135     data_ = ReadTestDataFile(GetParam().filename);
 136     protocol_.reset(
 137         new InMemoryUrlProtocol(data_->data(), data_->data_size(), false));
 138     reader_.reset(new AudioFileReader(protocol_.get()));
 139     ASSERT_TRUE(reader_->OpenDemuxerForTesting());
 140
 141     // Load the first packet and check its timestamp.
 142     AVPacket packet;
 143     ASSERT_TRUE(reader_->ReadPacketForTesting(&packet));
 144     EXPECT_EQ(GetParam().first_packet_pts, packet.pts);
 145     start_timestamp_ = ConvertFromTimeBase(
 146         reader_->GetAVStreamForTesting()->time_base, packet.pts);
 147     av_free_packet(&packet);
 148
 149     // Seek back to the beginning.
 150     ASSERT_TRUE(reader_->SeekForTesting(start_timestamp_));
 151
 152     AudioDecoderConfig config;
 153     AVCodecContextToAudioDecoderConfig(
 154         reader_->codec_context_for_testing(), false, &config, false);
 155
 156     EXPECT_EQ(GetParam().codec, config.codec());
 157     EXPECT_EQ(GetParam().samples_per_second, config.samples_per_second());
 158     EXPECT_EQ(GetParam().channel_layout, config.channel_layout());
 159
 160     InitializeDecoder(config);
 161   }
 162
 163   void InitializeDecoder(const AudioDecoderConfig& config) {
 164     InitializeDecoderWithStatus(config, PIPELINE_OK);
 165   }
 166
 167   void InitializeDecoderWithStatus(const AudioDecoderConfig& config,
 168                                    PipelineStatus status) {
 169     decoder_->Initialize(
 170         config,
 171         NewExpectedStatusCB(status),
 172         base::Bind(&AudioDecoderTest::OnDecoderOutput, base::Unretained(this)));
 173     base::RunLoop().RunUntilIdle();
 174   }
 175
 176   void Decode() {
 177     AVPacket packet;
 178     ASSERT_TRUE(reader_->ReadPacketForTesting(&packet));
 179
 180     // Split out packet metadata before making a copy.
 181     av_packet_split_side_data(&packet);
 182
 183     scoped_refptr<DecoderBuffer> buffer =
 184         DecoderBuffer::CopyFrom(packet.data, packet.size);
 185     buffer->set_timestamp(ConvertFromTimeBase(
 186         reader_->GetAVStreamForTesting()->time_base, packet.pts));
 187     buffer->set_duration(ConvertFromTimeBase(
 188         reader_->GetAVStreamForTesting()->time_base, packet.duration));
 189
 190     // Don't set discard padding for Opus, it already has discard behavior set
 191     // based on the codec delay in the AudioDecoderConfig.
 192     if (GetParam().decoder_type == FFMPEG)
 193       SetDiscardPadding(&packet, buffer, GetParam().samples_per_second);
 194
 195     // DecodeBuffer() shouldn't need the original packet since it uses the copy.
 196     av_free_packet(&packet);
 197     DecodeBuffer(buffer);
 198   }
 199
 200   void Reset() {
 201     ASSERT_FALSE(pending_reset_);
 202     pending_reset_ = true;
 203     decoder_->Reset(
 204         base::Bind(&AudioDecoderTest::ResetFinished, base::Unretained(this)));
 205     base::RunLoop().RunUntilIdle();
 206     ASSERT_FALSE(pending_reset_);
 207   }
 208
 209   void Seek(base::TimeDelta seek_time) {
 210     Reset();
 211     decoded_audio_.clear();
 212     ASSERT_TRUE(reader_->SeekForTesting(seek_time));
 213   }
 214
 215   void OnDecoderOutput(const scoped_refptr<AudioBuffer>& buffer) {
 216     EXPECT_FALSE(buffer->end_of_stream());
 217     decoded_audio_.push_back(buffer);
 218   }
 219
 220   void DecodeFinished(AudioDecoder::Status status) {
 221     EXPECT_TRUE(pending_decode_);
 222     EXPECT_FALSE(pending_reset_);
 223     pending_decode_ = false;
 224     last_decode_status_ = status;
 225   }
 226
 227   void ResetFinished() {
 228     EXPECT_TRUE(pending_reset_);
 229     EXPECT_FALSE(pending_decode_);
 230     pending_reset_ = false;
 231   }
 232
 233   // Generates an MD5 hash of the audio signal.  Should not be used for checks
 234   // across platforms as audio varies slightly across platforms.
 235   std::string GetDecodedAudioMD5(size_t i) {
 236     CHECK_LT(i, decoded_audio_.size());
 237     const scoped_refptr<AudioBuffer>& buffer = decoded_audio_[i];
 238
 239     scoped_ptr<AudioBus> output =
 240         AudioBus::Create(buffer->channel_count(), buffer->frame_count());
 241     buffer->ReadFrames(buffer->frame_count(), 0, 0, output.get());
 242
 243     base::MD5Context context;
 244     base::MD5Init(&context);
 245     for (int ch = 0; ch < output->channels(); ++ch) {
 246       base::MD5Update(
 247           &context,
 248           base::StringPiece(reinterpret_cast<char*>(output->channel(ch)),
 249                             output->frames() * sizeof(*output->channel(ch))));
 250     }
 251     base::MD5Digest digest;
 252     base::MD5Final(&digest, &context);
 253     return base::MD5DigestToBase16(digest);
 254   }
 255
 256   void ExpectDecodedAudio(size_t i, const std::string& exact_hash) {
 257     CHECK_LT(i, decoded_audio_.size());
 258     const scoped_refptr<AudioBuffer>& buffer = decoded_audio_[i];
 259
 260     const DecodedBufferExpectations& sample_info = GetParam().expectations[i];
 261     EXPECT_EQ(sample_info.timestamp, buffer->timestamp().InMicroseconds());
 262     EXPECT_EQ(sample_info.duration, buffer->duration().InMicroseconds());
 263     EXPECT_FALSE(buffer->end_of_stream());
 264
 265     scoped_ptr<AudioBus> output =
 266         AudioBus::Create(buffer->channel_count(), buffer->frame_count());
 267     buffer->ReadFrames(buffer->frame_count(), 0, 0, output.get());
 268
 269     // Generate a lossy hash of the audio used for comparison across platforms.
 270     AudioHash audio_hash;
 271     audio_hash.Update(output.get(), output->frames());
 272     EXPECT_EQ(sample_info.hash, audio_hash.ToString());
 273
 274     if (!exact_hash.empty()) {
 275       EXPECT_EQ(exact_hash, GetDecodedAudioMD5(i));
 276
 277       // Verify different hashes are being generated.  None of our test data
 278       // files have audio that hashes out exactly the same.
 279       if (i > 0)
 280         EXPECT_NE(exact_hash, GetDecodedAudioMD5(i - 1));
 281     }
 282   }
 283
 284   size_t decoded_audio_size() const { return decoded_audio_.size(); }
 285   base::TimeDelta start_timestamp() const { return start_timestamp_; }
 286   const scoped_refptr<AudioBuffer>& decoded_audio(size_t i) {
 287     return decoded_audio_[i];
 288   }
 289   AudioDecoder::Status last_decode_status() const {
 290     return last_decode_status_;
 291   }
 292
 293  private:
 294   base::MessageLoop message_loop_;
 295   scoped_refptr<DecoderBuffer> data_;
 296   scoped_ptr<InMemoryUrlProtocol> protocol_;
 297   scoped_ptr<AudioFileReader> reader_;
 298
 299   scoped_ptr<AudioDecoder> decoder_;
 300   bool pending_decode_;
 301   bool pending_reset_;
 302   AudioDecoder::Status last_decode_status_;
 303
 304   std::deque<scoped_refptr<AudioBuffer> > decoded_audio_;
 305   base::TimeDelta start_timestamp_;
 306
 307   DISALLOW_COPY_AND_ASSIGN(AudioDecoderTest);
 308 };
 309
 310 class OpusAudioDecoderBehavioralTest : public AudioDecoderTest {};
 311 class FFmpegAudioDecoderBehavioralTest : public AudioDecoderTest {};
 312
 313 TEST_P(AudioDecoderTest, Initialize) {
 314   ASSERT_NO_FATAL_FAILURE(Initialize());
 315 }
 316
 317 // Verifies decode audio as well as the Decode() -> Reset() sequence.
 318 TEST_P(AudioDecoderTest, ProduceAudioSamples) {
 319   ASSERT_NO_FATAL_FAILURE(Initialize());
 320
 321   // Run the test multiple times with a seek back to the beginning in between.
 322   std::vector<std::string> decoded_audio_md5_hashes;
 323   for (int i = 0; i < 2; ++i) {
 324     for (size_t j = 0; j < kDecodeRuns; ++j) {
 325       do {
 326         Decode();
 327         ASSERT_EQ(last_decode_status(), AudioDecoder::kOk);
 328         // Some codecs have a multiple buffer delay and require an extra
 329         // Decode() step to extract the desired number of output buffers.
 330       } while (j == 0 && decoded_audio_size() == 0);
 331
 332       // On the first pass record the exact MD5 hash for each decoded buffer.
 333       if (i == 0)
 334         decoded_audio_md5_hashes.push_back(GetDecodedAudioMD5(j));
 335     }
 336
 337     ASSERT_EQ(kDecodeRuns, decoded_audio_size());
 338
 339     // On the first pass verify the basic audio hash and sample info.  On the
 340     // second, verify the exact MD5 sum for each packet.  It shouldn't change.
 341     for (size_t j = 0; j < kDecodeRuns; ++j) {
 342       SCOPED_TRACE(base::StringPrintf("i = %d, j = %" PRIuS, i, j));
 343       ExpectDecodedAudio(j, i == 0 ? "" : decoded_audio_md5_hashes[j]);
 344     }
 345
 346     SendEndOfStream();
 347     ASSERT_EQ(kDecodeRuns, decoded_audio_size());
 348
 349     // Seek back to the beginning.  Calls Reset() on the decoder.
 350     Seek(start_timestamp());
 351   }
 352 }
 353
 354 TEST_P(AudioDecoderTest, Decode) {
 355   ASSERT_NO_FATAL_FAILURE(Initialize());
 356   Decode();
 357   EXPECT_EQ(AudioDecoder::kOk, last_decode_status());
 358 }
 359
 360 TEST_P(AudioDecoderTest, Reset) {
 361   ASSERT_NO_FATAL_FAILURE(Initialize());
 362   Reset();
 363 }
 364
 365 TEST_P(AudioDecoderTest, NoTimestamp) {
 366   ASSERT_NO_FATAL_FAILURE(Initialize());
 367   scoped_refptr<DecoderBuffer> buffer(new DecoderBuffer(0));
 368   buffer->set_timestamp(kNoTimestamp());
 369   DecodeBuffer(buffer);
 370   EXPECT_EQ(AudioDecoder::kDecodeError, last_decode_status());
 371 }
 372
 373 TEST_P(OpusAudioDecoderBehavioralTest, InitializeWithNoCodecDelay) {
 374   ASSERT_EQ(GetParam().decoder_type, OPUS);
 375   AudioDecoderConfig decoder_config;
 376   decoder_config.Initialize(kCodecOpus,
 377                             kSampleFormatF32,
 378                             CHANNEL_LAYOUT_STEREO,
 379                             48000,
 380                             kOpusExtraData,
 381                             arraysize(kOpusExtraData),
 382                             false,
 383                             false,
 384                             base::TimeDelta::FromMilliseconds(80),
 385                             0);
 386   InitializeDecoder(decoder_config);
 387 }
 388
 389 TEST_P(OpusAudioDecoderBehavioralTest, InitializeWithBadCodecDelay) {
 390   ASSERT_EQ(GetParam().decoder_type, OPUS);
 391   AudioDecoderConfig decoder_config;
 392   decoder_config.Initialize(
 393       kCodecOpus,
 394       kSampleFormatF32,
 395       CHANNEL_LAYOUT_STEREO,
 396       48000,
 397       kOpusExtraData,
 398       arraysize(kOpusExtraData),
 399       false,
 400       false,
 401       base::TimeDelta::FromMilliseconds(80),
 402       // Use a different codec delay than in the extradata.
 403       100);
 404   InitializeDecoderWithStatus(decoder_config, DECODER_ERROR_NOT_SUPPORTED);
 405 }
 406
 407 TEST_P(FFmpegAudioDecoderBehavioralTest, InitializeWithBadConfig) {
 408   const AudioDecoderConfig decoder_config(kCodecVorbis,
 409                                           kSampleFormatF32,
 410                                           CHANNEL_LAYOUT_STEREO,
 411                                           // Invalid sample rate of zero.
 412                                           0,
 413                                           NULL,
 414                                           0,
 415                                           false);
 416   InitializeDecoderWithStatus(decoder_config, DECODER_ERROR_NOT_SUPPORTED);
 417 }
 418
 419 const DecodedBufferExpectations kSfxOpusExpectations[] = {
 420     {0, 13500, "-2.70,-1.41,-0.78,-1.27,-2.56,-3.73,"},
 421     {13500, 20000, "5.48,5.93,6.04,5.83,5.54,5.45,"},
 422     {33500, 20000, "-3.45,-3.35,-3.57,-4.12,-4.74,-5.14,"},
 423 };
 424
 425 const DecodedBufferExpectations kBearOpusExpectations[] = {
 426     {500, 3500, "-0.26,0.87,1.36,0.84,-0.30,-1.22,"},
 427     {4000, 10000, "0.09,0.23,0.21,0.03,-0.17,-0.24,"},
 428     {14000, 10000, "0.10,0.24,0.23,0.04,-0.14,-0.23,"},
 429 };
 430
 431 const DecoderTestData kOpusTests[] = {
 432     {OPUS, kCodecOpus, "sfx-opus.ogg", kSfxOpusExpectations, -312, 48000,
 433      CHANNEL_LAYOUT_MONO},
 434     {OPUS, kCodecOpus, "bear-opus.ogg", kBearOpusExpectations, 24, 48000,
 435      CHANNEL_LAYOUT_STEREO},
 436 };
 437
 438 // Dummy data for behavioral tests.
 439 const DecoderTestData kOpusBehavioralTest[] = {
 440     {OPUS, kUnknownAudioCodec, "", NULL, 0, 0, CHANNEL_LAYOUT_NONE},
 441 };
 442
 443 INSTANTIATE_TEST_CASE_P(OpusAudioDecoderTest,
 444                         AudioDecoderTest,
 445                         testing::ValuesIn(kOpusTests));
 446 INSTANTIATE_TEST_CASE_P(OpusAudioDecoderBehavioralTest,
 447                         OpusAudioDecoderBehavioralTest,
 448                         testing::ValuesIn(kOpusBehavioralTest));
 449
 450 #if defined(USE_PROPRIETARY_CODECS)
 451 const DecodedBufferExpectations kSfxMp3Expectations[] = {
 452     {0, 1065, "2.81,3.99,4.53,4.10,3.08,2.46,"},
 453     {1065, 26122, "-3.81,-4.14,-3.90,-3.36,-3.03,-3.23,"},
 454     {27188, 26122, "4.24,3.95,4.22,4.78,5.13,4.93,"},
 455 };
 456
 457 const DecodedBufferExpectations kSfxAdtsExpectations[] = {
 458     {0, 23219, "-1.90,-1.53,-0.15,1.28,1.23,-0.33,"},
 459     {23219, 23219, "0.54,0.88,2.19,3.54,3.24,1.63,"},
 460     {46439, 23219, "1.42,1.69,2.95,4.23,4.02,2.36,"},
 461 };
 462 #endif
 463
 464 #if defined(OS_CHROMEOS)
 465 const DecodedBufferExpectations kSfxFlacExpectations[] = {
 466     {0, 104489, "-2.42,-1.12,0.71,1.70,1.09,-0.68,"},
 467     {104489, 104489, "-1.99,-0.67,1.18,2.19,1.60,-0.16,"},
 468     {208979, 79433, "2.84,2.70,3.23,4.06,4.59,4.44,"},
 469 };
 470 #endif
 471
 472 const DecodedBufferExpectations kSfxWaveExpectations[] = {
 473     {0, 23219, "-1.23,-0.87,0.47,1.85,1.88,0.29,"},
 474     {23219, 23219, "0.75,1.10,2.43,3.78,3.53,1.93,"},
 475     {46439, 23219, "1.27,1.56,2.83,4.13,3.87,2.23,"},
 476 };
 477
 478 const DecodedBufferExpectations kFourChannelWaveExpectations[] = {
 479     {0, 11609, "-1.68,1.68,0.89,-3.45,1.52,1.15,"},
 480     {11609, 11609, "43.26,9.06,18.27,35.98,19.45,7.46,"},
 481     {23219, 11609, "36.37,9.45,16.04,27.67,18.81,10.15,"},
 482 };
 483
 484 const DecodedBufferExpectations kSfxOggExpectations[] = {
 485     {0, 13061, "-0.33,1.25,2.86,3.26,2.09,0.14,"},
 486     {13061, 23219, "-2.79,-2.42,-1.06,0.33,0.93,-0.64,"},
 487     {36281, 23219, "-1.19,-0.80,0.57,1.97,2.08,0.51,"},
 488 };
 489
 490 const DecodedBufferExpectations kBearOgvExpectations[] = {
 491     {0, 13061, "-1.25,0.10,2.11,2.29,1.50,-0.68,"},
 492     {13061, 23219, "-1.80,-1.41,-0.13,1.30,1.65,0.01,"},
 493     {36281, 23219, "-1.43,-1.25,0.11,1.29,1.86,0.14,"},
 494 };
 495
 496 const DecoderTestData kFFmpegTests[] = {
 497 #if defined(USE_PROPRIETARY_CODECS)
 498     {FFMPEG, kCodecMP3, "sfx.mp3", kSfxMp3Expectations, 0, 44100,
 499      CHANNEL_LAYOUT_MONO},
 500     {FFMPEG, kCodecAAC, "sfx.adts", kSfxAdtsExpectations, 0, 44100,
 501      CHANNEL_LAYOUT_MONO},
 502 #endif
 503 #if defined(OS_CHROMEOS)
 504     {FFMPEG, kCodecFLAC, "sfx.flac", kSfxFlacExpectations, 0, 44100,
 505      CHANNEL_LAYOUT_MONO},
 506 #endif
 507     {FFMPEG, kCodecPCM, "sfx_f32le.wav", kSfxWaveExpectations, 0, 44100,
 508      CHANNEL_LAYOUT_MONO},
 509     {FFMPEG, kCodecPCM, "4ch.wav", kFourChannelWaveExpectations, 0, 44100,
 510      CHANNEL_LAYOUT_QUAD},
 511     {FFMPEG, kCodecVorbis, "sfx.ogg", kSfxOggExpectations, 0, 44100,
 512      CHANNEL_LAYOUT_MONO},
 513     // Note: bear.ogv is incorrectly muxed such that valid samples are given
 514     // negative timestamps, this marks them for discard per the ogg vorbis spec.
 515     {FFMPEG, kCodecVorbis, "bear.ogv", kBearOgvExpectations, -704, 44100,
 516      CHANNEL_LAYOUT_STEREO},
 517 };
 518
 519 // Dummy data for behavioral tests.
 520 const DecoderTestData kFFmpegBehavioralTest[] = {
 521     {FFMPEG, kUnknownAudioCodec, "", NULL, 0, 0, CHANNEL_LAYOUT_NONE},
 522 };
 523
 524 INSTANTIATE_TEST_CASE_P(FFmpegAudioDecoderTest,
 525                         AudioDecoderTest,
 526                         testing::ValuesIn(kFFmpegTests));
 527 INSTANTIATE_TEST_CASE_P(FFmpegAudioDecoderBehavioralTest,
 528                         FFmpegAudioDecoderBehavioralTest,
 529                         testing::ValuesIn(kFFmpegBehavioralTest));
 530
 531 }  // namespace media