opensles: Work around race condition in Android < 4.2 that leads to deadlocks on...

We need to sleep a bit before destroying the player object
because of a bug in Android in versions < 4.2.

OpenSLES is using AudioTrack for rendering the sound. AudioTrack
has a thread that pulls raw audio from the buffer queue and then
passes it forward to AudioFlinger (AudioTrack::processAudioBuffer()).
This thread is calling various callbacks on events, e.g. when
an underrun happens or to request data. OpenSLES sets this callback
on AudioTrack (audioTrack_callBack_pullFromBuffQueue() from
android_AudioPlayer.cpp). Among other things this is taking a lock
on the player interface.

Now if we destroy the player interface object, it will first of all
take the player interface lock (IObject_Destroy()). Then it destroys
the audio player instance (android_audioPlayer_destroy()) which then
calls stop() on the AudioTrack and deletes it. Now the destructor of
AudioTrack will wait until the rendering thread (AudioTrack::processAudioBuffer())
has finished.

If all this happens with bad timing it can happen that the rendering
thread is currently e.g. handling underrun but did not lock the player
interface object yet. Then destroying happens and takes the lock and waits
for the thread to finish. Then the thread tries to take the lock and waits
forever.

We wait a bit before destroying the player object to make sure that
the rendering thread finished whatever it was doing, and then stops
(note: we called gst_opensles_ringbuffer_stop() before this already).

diff --git a/sys/opensles/openslesringbuffer.c b/sys/opensles/openslesringbuffer.c
index 6e7f50a..59db1bb 100644 (file)
--- a/sys/opensles/openslesringbuffer.c
+++ b/sys/opensles/openslesringbuffer.c
@@ -801,8 +801,39 @@ gst_opensles_ringbuffer_release (GstAudioRingBuffer * rb)
 
   thiz = GST_OPENSLES_RING_BUFFER (rb);
 
+  /* XXX: We need to sleep a bit before destroying the player object
+   * because of a bug in Android in versions < 4.2.
+   *
+   * OpenSLES is using AudioTrack for rendering the sound. AudioTrack
+   * has a thread that pulls raw audio from the buffer queue and then
+   * passes it forward to AudioFlinger (AudioTrack::processAudioBuffer()).
+   * This thread is calling various callbacks on events, e.g. when
+   * an underrun happens or to request data. OpenSLES sets this callback
+   * on AudioTrack (audioTrack_callBack_pullFromBuffQueue() from
+   * android_AudioPlayer.cpp). Among other things this is taking a lock
+   * on the player interface.
+   *
+   * Now if we destroy the player interface object, it will first of all
+   * take the player interface lock (IObject_Destroy()). Then it destroys
+   * the audio player instance (android_audioPlayer_destroy()) which then
+   * calls stop() on the AudioTrack and deletes it. Now the destructor of
+   * AudioTrack will wait until the rendering thread (AudioTrack::processAudioBuffer())
+   * has finished.
+   *
+   * If all this happens with bad timing it can happen that the rendering
+   * thread is currently e.g. handling underrun but did not lock the player
+   * interface object yet. Then destroying happens and takes the lock and waits
+   * for the thread to finish. Then the thread tries to take the lock and waits
+   * forever.
+   *
+   * We wait a bit before destroying the player object to make sure that
+   * the rendering thread finished whatever it was doing, and then stops
+   * (note: we called gst_opensles_ringbuffer_stop() before this already).
+   */
+
   /* Destroy audio player object, and invalidate all associated interfaces */
   if (thiz->playerObject) {
+    g_usleep (50000);
     (*thiz->playerObject)->Destroy (thiz->playerObject);
     thiz->playerObject = NULL;
     thiz->playerPlay = NULL;
@@ -811,6 +842,7 @@ gst_opensles_ringbuffer_release (GstAudioRingBuffer * rb)
 
   /* Destroy audio recorder object, and invalidate all associated interfaces */
   if (thiz->recorderObject) {
+    g_usleep (50000);
     (*thiz->recorderObject)->Destroy (thiz->recorderObject);
     thiz->recorderObject = NULL;
     thiz->recorderRecord = NULL;